5/5 - (1 vote)

Over the course of my career as a baker, I’ve gained an understanding of how difficult it can be to get the ideal texture for a cake. Thank goodness, I had a guide by my side who taught me how to prevent making a cake that was crumbly when I baked it. Through the years, having the knowledge of how to avoid having a cake that crumbles has been a huge time and stress saver for me. With any luck, you won’t end up with a crumbly cake if you follow these suggestions.

It is possible to make a cake that is crumbly by using an excessive amount of flour, by overmixing the cake batter, by not adding sufficient shortening, or by not adding sufficient sugar. The presence of gluten in flour, whether in large or little quantities, has the potential to alter the structural integrity of the cake by making it more crumbly and moist.

In light of the fact that some bakers are still having trouble with crumbly cakes, I have resolved to do in-depth research into the reasons why a cake may sometimes be crumbly while at the same time being moist.

This in-depth investigation into the secrets of baking has provided me with a wide variety of workarounds and solutions that I continue to employ to this day in order to mend or avoid a crumbly and moist cake. Learning all of these straightforward answers has helped me become a better baker today. There are many other approaches that may be used to solve this issue.

Why Is Your Cake Crumbly

The amount of gluten in the flour that is used to make a cake determines whether or not the finished product will be crumbly and moist. Gluten may be found in flour, which is one of the ingredients. In order to bake a cake, an excessive quantity of flour must be used, which results in an excessive amount of gluten being added to the cake mix.

Because adding an excessive amount of gluten may change the texture of a cake after it has been baked, this might be detrimental to your cake.

In baking, gluten’s purpose is to provide structure to the baked items you create. This may include aspects such as the shape, texture, and even form. Gluten is a protein that is both sticky and flexible; hence, it is used in the baking of almost anything.

When you are baking anything in the oven, it is imperative that you utilize accurate measurements so that you may get the outcomes that you want. This is very necessary since an excessive amount of one component might result in insufficient amounts of the other elements.

If you do not add a enough amount of shortening to the cake mix, your finished product can turn out to be a disaster. The cake is held together with the assistance of shortening and several other sorts of high-fat components. It is essential to add the required amount of shortening, or as directed in the recipe, for your cake to turn out moist and cohesive rather than dry and crumbly.

A battery operated electric flour sifter for baking is, in my experience, the most effective instrument for me to use while sifting flour. This amazing kitchen appliance fulfills all of my sifting requirements in the kitchen with its automated capabilities. It can hold a total of 4 cups and can be cleaned easily. What more do you need in a machine that does sorting automatically? You can learn more about this Electric Flour Sifter by visiting Amazon.com.

If you do not add a sufficient amount of shortening, this may also signal that you have added too much flour to your cake. A high concentration of gluten in the batter will result in a cake that is dry, crumbly, and prone to coming apart, as was previously described.

The same thing happens when there isn’t enough sugar added. When I make cakes, I do my best to follow the instructions in the recipe as closely as I can. If you do not add sufficient sugar to your batter, you may end up adding an excessive amount of flour, which will cause it to become more thick.

Every baker should make it a point to steer clear of the critical error of adding an excessive amount of flour. Your cake will become very dry if you add an excessive amount of any kind of flour (normal flour, gluten-free flour, or any other type of flour).

Why Is Your Cake Moist

The absence of sufficient gluten in the cake batter causes the finished product to have an excessive amount of moisture. Cakes made with gluten-free flour tend to have a more crumbly texture and retain more moisture than cakes made with traditional wheat. Alternately, a cake that was cooked for a shorter amount of time may retain more moisture.

It is possible for a cake to have little gluten just as it is possible for it to have an excessive amount of gluten. Using gluten-free flour to bake a cake that is gluten-free might compromise the cake’s structural integrity, so keep that in mind if you’re planning on preparing a gluten-free cake. A cake that does not have gluten will be incapable of forming a solid texture, which will, in the end, cause your cake to have an excessive amount of moisture.

It’s possible that you removed the cake from the oven a little bit too soon, which would explain why it has a wet texture. As a baker who has accidentally removed her cakes from the oven too soon on several occasions, I can assure you that this is not the end of the world.

As soon as you can, place the cake back in the oven, and then immediately turn the temperature back up to where it was before. This will assist the cake in continuing the baking process without experiencing a significant loss of heat. Continue checking on your cake at even more frequent intervals to prevent it from overbaking.

If your cake does not have an excessive amount of moisture, I would recommend checking on it every few minutes to prevent it from being overbaked.

If, on the other hand, your cake is much too wet and you removed it from the oven way too soon, I would recommend checking on it every 5-7 minutes so that you don’t open the oven too often. If you open the oven door too often, your cake may deflate, and you will have an even greater problem to cope with.

When it comes to baking, having exact measures is essential, as was previously discussed. Having said that, some individuals like adapting the recipes and ingredients for their cupcakes to use in the preparation of their regular-sized cakes.

When it comes to producing the batter, this is one of the primary reasons why the measurements of the components could turn out to be incorrect. If you want a cake with a larger size, in addition to adding a few extra of each ingredient, I would recommend extending the amount of time the cake spends in the oven.

Make sure that your cake batter has an adequate amount of flour in it to avoid producing a cake that is too moist. This will aid in thickening your mixture and providing it with the proper consistency.

Why do your cakes fall apart?

Cakes that have been cooked for too long tend to crumble when sliced, which is often the result of overbaking. If you overbake a cake, the end result will be a cake that is overly solid. If you remove an overbaked cake from its pan too fast after it has been removed from the oven, the cake may break apart because the inside of the cake has not yet settled.

Even though all of these errors are widespread, the one that I see bakers do that is the most common is overmixing their batter. To have a better grasp on why it is a bad idea, we must first investigate the motivations for the mixing of the cake batter in the first place.

Mixing the cake batter combines the dry and wet components while also adding air into the mixture. This is necessary in order to make a cake. The addition of air to the batter will give the finished product a pleasant, light and airy consistency.

If you overmix your cake batter, you will end up adding an excessive amount of air to the mixture, which will have the opposite effect on the finished cake. If you do this to your cake, it will disintegrate and become unusable once you begin cutting it.

How to prevent a cake from crumbling?

To avoid a cake from falling apart as a whole, it is important to strictly adhere to the cake’s recipe. When making a cake, it is necessary to utilize accurate measures and proportions of all of the components. It is essential that you stick your cake in the oven for the precise amount of time that is outlined in the recipe.

When it comes to baking, you have to adhere slavishly to the specific measures outlined in your chosen recipes as if your very existence depended on it.

Not only do you have to make sure that the proportions you use for the ingredients are accurate, but you also have to make sure that the ratio you use to incorporate the ingredients into the dish is accurate.

For instance, if we are developing a recipe that calls for one cup of sugar, we will want around one and a half cups of flour. If you use the appropriate ratios, you won’t end up with either too much flour or too enough sugar. This, in turn, will assist in preventing a cake from becoming crumbly.

The amount of time spent baking is also very crucial, on par with the components. If you leave your cake in the oven for just five minutes longer than the instructions for the recipe call for, you run the risk of ending up with an overbaked cake that is dry and crumbly.

Another potential cause of your cake’s crumbly texture is if you open the oven door too often. When you often open your oven’s door, the heat that has been building up inside of it might quickly escape. It’s possible that you won’t notice it right away, but if you take your cake out of the oven before the end of the allotted time after the oven door has been opened, your cake will be undercooked.

Because of this, you will need to place the cake inside the oven once more to complete the baking process. In most cases, you shouldn’t be very concerned with that aspect of things. On the other hand, the cake can turn out to be dry and crumbly if you wind up placing it in the oven for a second time.

How do you fix a crumbly cake?

A cake that is crumbly may often be fixed by increasing the amount of high-fat content ingredients, such as butter and oils. Ingredients with a greater fat content have the ability to bind the cake’s otherwise crumbly components together. When you cut the cake, this will prevent the cake from falling apart and help keep it together.

I would suggest that you include applesauce, yogurt, bananas, or even dates into your combination if you are looking for a lower-calorie and lower-fat alternative to the high-fat items that you are currently using.

These other ingredients, once pureed, will impart more moisture into your cake, so preventing it from drying out. Those who choose this cake will still benefit from its reduced calorie content thanks to these substitutions.

When I initially ran into this issue, I had to think fast on my feet in order to find a solution since I was about to serve this cake to my guests in a short amount of time. After giving it some consideration, I came to the conclusion that including some kind of wetness into my cake may make it stickier while preventing it from coming apart.

Because, at the time, I was unaware that the combination may benefit from the addition of a high-fat content of any type, I covered the cake’s flaws by covering it with icing and a large number of cake decorations instead of adding the high-fat content.

Why is your cake dry and crumbly?

Overbaking a cake or using an excessive amount of flour may cause it to become dry and crumbly over its whole. A cake will lose all of its moisture if it is baked for an excessively long period of time, and wheat includes gluten, which, when present in high enough concentrations, may compromise the cake’s structural integrity by leaving it dry and crumbly.

When making a cake, the most difficult step is when you add the flour. When I follow a recipe, one of the things that I always pay attention to is whether or not I have added the appropriate amount of flour.

Too much flour = Dry and crumbly cake

In the course of their work, bakers often make the error of cooking a cake for too long. Even among the most experienced and skilled bakers, it is not an unusual occurrence.

It is not all that difficult to accidently overbake your cake if you are not paying attention. You might follow the directions for your recipe to the letter, but if you increase the temperature of your oven by even a few degrees over what is called for in the recipe, you will end up with a cake that is overbaked and dry.

There is also the potential that, while you were attending to other responsibilities, you inadvertently let your cake to remain in the oven for a few more minutes. This will cause the moisture in your cake to evaporate, leaving you with a cake that is dry and crumbly no matter what you do!


Why is my cake too soft and breaking?

The batter has an excessive amount of raising agent in it. A cake that has been baked with an excessive amount of baking powder may rise excessively and too rapidly, which may cause it to break or overflow the edges of the pan. A more equal surface may be achieved by reducing the quantity of raising agent used or by using a mix of plain wheat and flour that already contains leavening.

Why do cakes break after baking?

When the temperature in the oven is set too high, the outside of the cake cooks at a considerably quicker pace than the inside of the cake. Early on, a crust will develop, but as the cake continues to bake and rise, a crack will appear on the surface of the crust. It’s possible that you’ll run into the same issue if the cake recipe calls for an excessive amount of leavener or if you use a baking dish that’s not large enough.

What is the best temperature for baking cake?

The temperature at which most cakes are baked may range anywhere from 325F to 450F, with 350F being the most typical temperature. If you are not sure what temperature to use, I suggest setting your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and inspecting it after 30 minutes has passed. Utilize a thermometer to check that the temperature of your cake is just right!

How do you cut a cake without it crumbling?

You should associate with hot water. If you have time to cool your cake before cutting it, you may make slicing it even simpler by running your knife under hot water before using it. This works even if you don’t have time to chill your cake. Make sure the knife is completely dry before using it, and then cut your slices while the knife is still just barely warm to the touch.