Rate this post

Carrot cake is one of those cakes that I don’t feel bad about eating. Over the Christmas season, I was cooking a carrot cake and wondering how long it would last. I wanted to know how quickly carrot cakes deteriorate, so I decided to conduct some research on carrot cake shelf life.

Carrot cake will often degrade in 2 days if left out at room temperature. Carrot cake may be preserved in an airtight container for approximately 5 days. Once wrapped and refrigerated, a carrot cake will keep for approximately a week. Carrot cake may be frozen for up to three months.

Carrot cake is an excellent way to include some nutrients into your dessert without compromising its delectable flavor. If you’re going to bake a carrot cake soon and want to know how to preserve it and prevent it from rotting, you’ve come to the perfect spot! Learn about the shelf life differences between frosted and unfrosted carrot cakes.

How Long Will Carrot Cake Keep?

If it hasn’t previously been iced, a carrot cake may keep for approximately a week. If it has been frosted, it will keep for approximately two or three days. In any case, the carrot cake must be stored in an airtight container to keep its flavor and freshness.

In general, carrot cake keeps its taste well, but if it hasn’t been properly preserved, you may notice some concerns about five days after it’s been cooked.

The cream cheese icing that gives carrot cake its exquisite flavor is also what causes it to lose freshness over time. This is due to the fact that if cream cheese is not properly refrigerated, it might melt within a few hours.

Up to 12 inch 3-layer cakes may be stored in this container. This container was ideal for transporting my enormous cakes. This Cake Storage Jar is available on Amazon! * By the way, I’ve always wanted to be able to properly preserve my cakes, but I’ve never found a nice container that could accommodate my enormous cakes. I did, however, come across an Extra Large Cake Carrier lately.

If you haven’t taken care to properly keep your cake, the healthy boost from the carrots may become a problem. If fruits and vegetables are kept in the heat for too long, they will deteriorate. When I bake with fruits and veggies, I strive to be extra cautious.

Is Carrot Cake Spilt? Does it go wrong?

Carrot cake, in general, may decay if not kept correctly. Carrot cake may go bad in two days if kept at room temperature. As it starts to lose freshness, you will notice a difference in fragrance and texture.

Most cakes, such as chocolate and vanilla-based cakes, hold up well when left out for a short period of time. When making a cake with cream cheese icing and carrots, however, you must take additional steps to avoid spoiling.

When baking with dairy-based items such as cream cheese, keep in mind that spoilt dairy might make you ill if you don’t properly store your completed product.

I don’t want a sick dinner guest who got sick after eating my dessert! This would be a nightmare for me since I like baking and sharing my products with family and friends.

That is why understanding how to properly preserve carrot cake is critical!

*Side Note: You may also be interested in learning how to properly store cake batter. I created an article on Storing Cake Batter Correctly, which you can read here!

How Should Carrot Cake Be Stored?

Carrot cake must be thoroughly cooled before storing in an airtight container. To keep the cake from oxidizing, store it in a cake container or other airtight plastic container. It will keep fresh for a week in a climate-controlled refrigerator.

Counter Top Sealed Container Refrigerator Freezer
Can last for 2 days if left out at room temperature Can last for 5 days Can last for up to a week Can last for up to 3 months

If you want to consume your cake within a week, the refrigerator is the ideal place to keep it. Like with other cakes, exposure to air will cause it to lose its quality, so use an airtight container. You may enjoy your carrot cake for approximately a week if you store it in the refrigerator.

If you bake your carrot cake ahead of time and need a longer-lasting storage option, the freezer is your best solution. It will keep in the freezer for approximately three months. If you use this procedure, be certain that you have not frosted it!

When it comes to long-term preservation, cream cheese frosting does not do well.

Remember to cover your cake in plastic wrap before placing it in your storage container. This will help avoid freezer burn while also preserving the quality.

*You may also be interested in Does German Chocolate Cake Spoil? I just created a post on The Best Way to Store German Chocolate Cake to Keep It Fresh, which you can read here!

How Can You Know Whether a Carrot Cake Is Bad?

When carrot cake starts to smell nasty, it’s time to throw it out. As it starts to lose its freshness, you will notice a change in texture. Mold will begin to develop on the top and interior of the cake, and it will seem and taste dry and crumbly.

You’ll know if the carrot cake has gone bad soon and without any dispute. Desserts with cream cheese icing are really scrumptious! Nevertheless, when it comes to expiry, cream cheese is one of the most difficult foods to manage with.

Cream cheese is a dairy product that, like any other dairy product, can deteriorate if not properly refrigerated.

I’ve mistakenly left cream cheese out for too long and had to toss it away since it split and ruined in only a few hours.

When the frosting on your carrot cake begins to melt and separate, it is time to discard it. This is a clear indicator that you either neglected to keep it correctly or that it has passed its expiration date.

*By the way, if you want to know how to remove stuck parchment off of your cake and how to avoid it, I just published an article on Removing Stuck Parchment Paper, which you can see here!

Is it necessary to refrigerate carrot cake?

Carrot cake must be refrigerated. If the carrot cake is not adequately chilled, the cream cheese icing will begin to melt as it sets out. Since most carrot cakes include dairy products, they must be refrigerated in an airtight container.

If you want to consume your cake later in the day, store it in the refrigerator until you are ready to eat it.

Nevertheless, if you expect to consume your carrot cake within an hour after baking it, you won’t need to chill it. After it has cooled and been frosted, it should last approximately two hours at room temperature before the frosting begins to melt.

Is it possible to freeze carrot cake?

Unfrosted carrot cake may be refrigerated to preserve its freshness. To avoid freezer burn, cover the carrot cake in plastic wrap before storing it in an airtight container. With appropriate storage, frozen carrot cake may last up to three months.

Absolutely, as long as the carrot cake has not been iced, it may be frozen. When I make multiple cakes ahead of time, I put them in the freezer.

The most important thing to remember while freezing your cake is to take the additional precaution of wrapping it in plastic wrap to retain its freshness. This may seem absurd at first, but it really keeps the cakes fresher for longer!

*Side Note: You may also be interested in learning How To Know When Your Banana Bread Is Done. I just published an essay titled The Correct Way to Repair Undercooked Banana Bread. This article may be found here!

Is it possible to make carrot cake ahead of time?

As a general rule, carrot cake may be made ahead of time. Make the carrot cake ahead of time and keep it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a week. To keep the carrot cake fresh, you may store it in the freezer for up to three months.

The approach you choose is ultimately determined by when you want to consume it. Carrot cake may be kept in the fridge for approximately a week if you take precautions to keep it from drying out.

You may be concerned about what happens when you take it out of the fridge. I despise the flavor and feel of a cold, hard cake, which is precisely what occurs when you eat it straight from the fridge. Carrot cake has to warm up a little before you can really appreciate its flavor and texture!

It’s a good idea to leave it out for an hour or two. This enables it to gradually warm up and allows the cream cheese icing to soften somewhat.

One of the many distinguishing characteristics of carrot cake is its mouthfeel. As a result, it is important to let it to warm up before serving so that you and your guests may enjoy this timeless favorite!

Although I like doing my mixing by hand, I greatly prefer using a stand mixer. I just posted an article on the 3 Best Stand Mixers for Bakers at Every Stage of Their Baking Journey. After an examination of many stand mixers, the KitchenAid Artisan Tilt-Head Stand Mixer was named the Best Overall Mixer. This stand mixer is available on Amazon!


Is it necessary to chill unfrosted carrot cake?

Unfrosted carrot cake does not need to be refrigerated unless you wish to preserve it for more than two days. If you are not going to consume it right away, put it in an airtight container in the refrigerator. This preserves the carrot cake for around seven days.

How should carrot cake be stored before frosting?

A carrot cake may be kept in an airtight container in the fridge for a week before icing. If keeping the carrot cake in the freezer, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap before putting it in an airtight container. This will protect it from freezer burn.

How do you keep carrot cake overnight?

For storing carrot cake overnight, wrap it in plastic wrap or keep it in an airtight food storage container. You may store the carrot cake on the counter or in an area of the refrigerator that is not subject to temperature fluctuations, such as the front.

How should carrot cake with cream cheese icing be stored?

Carrot cake that has previously been iced must be totally cooled before storing. Refrigerate it in a plastic cake container or plastic food storage container for up to a week. The cold will keep the dairy products in the frosting fresher for a longer period of time.

How long will carrot cake with cream cheese icing keep in the refrigerator?

Carrot cake with cream cheese icing can keep in the fridge for approximately a week if properly preserved. If the cake is kept in the fridge for more than a week, the freshness will begin to disappear and the cake may dry up. For a longer-lasting cake, store the carrot cake and cream cheese icing separately.

Is carrot cake made with carrots?

Carrot cake is often prepared with diced carrots added into the cake mixture. The carrots soften while baking, giving the cake a velvety texture. Carrots become sweet when baked, making them an ideal ingredient to this dish.

In conclusion

If you’re anything like me, you undoubtedly have a sweet tooth. As much as I like pastries, cakes, and cookies, I know I must be cautious not to overindulge in these delectably sweet sweets (particularly over the holidays)!

Carrot cakes have been in my family for centuries and allow us bakers to consume dessert without feeling bad! I hope these suggestions help you properly keep your carrot cake so you may enjoy it later!